Having finally watched STC and after having seen every episode of P2 to date, I can honestly say I WANT MORE STAR TREK!!!. I don't care who makes it. I've even started working my way through the lesser productions out there; Farragut, Voyage Trekkers (comedy - very well done), Potamkin, that weird german one, whatever. If it says ST, I'm all over it. Even the podcasts that I have found have some gold to be mined; Trekcast on iTunes is excellent - 2 fans with a connection to the old Vegas Experience going on about all things Trek and they are not uber nerds either. Good listening.
That being said, and having grown up watching TOS, I will say I am partial to P2 (I'm here aren't I?!). I've been following P2 for a couple years since I found out about it. IMO they are the closest to "real TOS" out there. (James is nutty fanatic about accuracy! - but in a good way!
) This summer I actually got to work on set for a week. James and team are some of the nicest, most dedicated fans, yet professional people you will ever meet. (and did I mention, I was on the friggin Bridge!! THE BRIDGE!!
I haven't met the STC crew but I can say this; I was on thier Facebook site and posted a mild criticism about Vic's acting as well as praise for the episode. I was immediately banned from the page. Talk about thin skinned. So I guess if i want to see a bad Shatner imitating, thin voiced, short, flouncy, over bearing, tin plated dictator with delusions of god-hood
, I know where to go! (too much?)